This actor should be sent to Pakistan for a formal training!!!Why are the producer and director of this film glorifying Azmal Kasav? Govt of India is spending crores of Rupees for the security of Kasav who had taken away so many innocent lives. Is our secular govt waiting for another Kandahar to happen so that they may set this criminal free in exchange of some pot belly politicians? In West Bengal a few years back a poor security guard called Dhananjay Bhattacharjee was accused of raping & killing a girl. He was convicted and hanging was ordered against this poor man whose trail was doubtful because his family could not afford to appoint a good lawyer for his defense. That time some, intellectuals, wife and daughter of Sri Buddhadev Bhattacharjee( the then CM of West Bengal)were on the road and demanded execution of Dhananjay. The poor fellow was hanged. Now why are not those people doing the same, come on the road and demand execution of Kasav? Want to demonstrate secularism?

We are not living in a jungle I guess mr. blackrose. And there should not be any doubt that he will not be hanged but we cannot have summary executions like Iran or Somalia as we are a democratic country with a lot of responsibility.

vani@ your statement is full of ambiguity.We need not have to show responsibilities towards the irresponsible. What I want to mean is that why the intelligentsia is not vocal in case of Kasav, when they were so vocal against that poor fellow ? If speedy execution does not take place then this would trigger more Kasavs to commit genocides elsewhere in India and would lead peaceful, secured life as guests of the Govt of India.This way Govt of India is offering a scope to some Pakistan based terrorist outfits like Al Kaida,Laskar-E -taiba,bangladesh's Jamat-E islam to abduct some eminent politicians/ hijack a passanger aircraft and then they would demand their release against Kasav which we had seen in case of Kandahar, where a Pakistani terrorist was released in exchange of some passengers and our Govt could not arraign for a commando operation to free the hostages.The Govt should show responsibility towards it's own citizens, protect their lives at any cost.

@BLACKROSE, if you know anything about "the poor fellow" convicted rapist and murderer Dhananjay that the law does not know, you need to tell THEM (the authorities) about it rather than make broad insinuations.

Khair@ The law and the legal system had convicted that fellow. His speedy execution was demanded by some people belonging to the higher strata of the society. What I wanted to mean is that why these people are not on the roads to demand speedy execution of Kasav? The crime committed by Kasav was well documented, the entire nation had witnessed this massacre.I want to highlight the double standard maintained by those people. Being common people we can only express our resentments in public forum like this. Another thing is also true that the outcome of a judicial trial largely depends upon the quality of the lawyer defending the accused, that is why rich people appoint Barristers to defend them. Theses Barristers charge lakhs of rupees per appearance. In fact in certain cases they may influence the judgement also. For a poor fellow this quality of legal defense is not available. This is very simple logic which you had ignored. However you are silent about the Kasov part in your comment

@BLACKROSE, this is why people regularly point out your ignorance on this forum. VANI had given an appropriate reply to this which it seems you did not understand. The law does not work on demands. It works on procedures. Good citizens let law take its own course while pandas and dadageers try to make demands on the law. Your fear of barristers charging lakhs of rupees coming to the defence of Kasab is not well founded. I am not in the business of demanding punishment from the law, that I'll leave to people like you who have had lot of practice in the streets of Kolkata (chai, chai, chai). However, I am happy to raise my voice to ask for justice.

Khair@ you and Vani( banu) complement each other well! My point is that some good citizens demanded "Chi Chi Chi" in case of that poor fellow. That is supportable, but why no " Chi Chi Chi" in case of Kasav or Afzal Guru? Your statement "I am not in the business of demanding punishment from the law " is funny. Then what for people go to the court of justice? You had used terms like ""the poor fellow" convicted rapist and murderer Dhananjay " but you are absolutely silent on the crime committed by Kasov who I feel that those people who did " chai chai chai" for the punishment of that poor fellow are sacred of repeating "chai chai chai" because it might create a spot on their secular image.This hypocrisy is intolerable.

@More lies from you: YOU had used the word "this poor man" in your post not me that is why I put it in quotes in my post. My only abberation was using the word "fellow" instead of "man".

See you missed the point again: good citizens do not DEMAND punishment from the law; they seek JUSTICE and if it is not forthcoming then they may demand justice too, but punishment is a matter for the law to decide.

I have no doubt Kasab will face the full force of the law and justice will be done and punishment will be meted out as per the law of the land. People have nothing to do with this matter now, least of all half baked dimwits like you.

Talking about demands, your brain demands some nourishment too. It is crying out loud "kichhu buddhi chai, gobor chai na".

@The term "convicted rapist and murderer Dhananjay " was used by you.Hence what's the point in telling lies Prof Khair? The question was not a debate on the term" man" or "fellow". the question is on the later part which I had mentioned under quote at the beginning of the block. Surprisingly you have avoided putting any adjectives in case of Kasav, whereas you were generous in showering adjectives in case of Dhananjay. My point was why no public demand in case of Kasav, which was given a spin by you and you took the discussion towards a different direction. You have not understood anything out of this. Dealt penalty was also declared againt Kasav, as in case of Afzal Guru. The point raised in various newspapers are why so much delay in execution. A part of Kolkata's intellectuals demanded speedy execution of Dhananjay, but why no such agitation in case of Kasav/Guru. I have serious doubts on your intelligence , which is aimed at identifying bigots only.Nobody is demanding...

cont.. any punishment,the question is why so much delay in execution, this delay might cause India to pay heavy prices. However I donot want to do an autopsy of your brain to identify whether it is filled with honest buddhi or suddha gobor of Australian oxe!!!Because only buddhi is not enough. It could be good or bad/honest or dishonest. Nobody would say that Kasav or Laden or Daud do not have buddhi, but the question is what type of buddhi do/did they have?Did or do they have honest buddhi or dishonest buddhi?

@BLACKROSE, more ignorant gobor from you. If you want to write a leaflet just do it instead of pretending to respond to a post?

I never heard of this Dhananjay. I first read about it in your post. Let us see what you wrote about him:-

You wrote:

"He was convicted "
HELLO!!! are you reading? YOU SAID that first; now you are saying:-
"The term "convicted" rapist and murderer Dhananjay was used by you"

Once again BLACKROSE, you have been caught red handed with your lies.

Previousy, you used the term "poor fellow" for Dhananjay, then lied and tried to make out that I had said it.

Please spare us from what the Kolkata intellectuals said! They must be of the same breed as you.

If he has already been given the death penalty what is your problem? He will be gone soon and you will have one less thing to talk about. Better start looking for another topic.