Classifieds   |   Contact Us Sign Up   |  

Forgot your password?


What is the best product or brand you have recently used? Write a review and share your experience with fellow consumers.

Admanya Logo
Write Review Write Blog
Things you can do
Stuff you may read

They say there's a book inside everybody. Let the book out with Admanya blogs. Vent your feelings about anything that pops into your head. It might be rocket science or your neighbour's cat.


Start now! Its easy and fun!

Line

Blog

Mamata Banerjee - Myth, Hype and Reality and The Future of West Bengal

Posted by FullMarx on 19 May 2011

READ: 2582

Mamata Banerjee - Myth, Hype and Reality and The Future of West Bengal As a communist I have no problems to congratulate Mamata on the eve of the day when the first woman chief minister of West Bengal will take oath in Raj Bhavan but I feel that a lot of myth and hype has shrouded the lady and the reality cannot be hidden for a long time.

Who is Mamata Banerjee?

To a person who has seen her from the days of early 80s, she is nothing a but an unpredictable and highly emotional political leader without any real agenda. Her sole agenda was to unseat the Left from power which she has been able to do because of her focus but after defeating the Left she is completely goal less.

Does she really lead a simple life?

Well, she is a person who tries to prove to masses that being well-off and well groomed is sort of a sin and so she wears a hawai chappal and simple cotton sarees as if that will solve the problem of poverty. This is nothing but hypocrisy and if she really is so unconcerned about her appearance then can she tell why she regularly dies her hair jet black? Does she have a problem to accept that graying is a natural process and she is over 50 now, no longer a young woman who once climbed on the bonnet of Jai Prakash Narayan's car to perform a "Tandava Nritya".

Is it not symbolism and trying to show that she is a poor person that she still lives in the semi slum area of Kalighat in a tiled roof house whereas she conducts her election campaigns in helicopters mainly. May be it will give her an excuse for not doing anything to raise the standard of living of poor and lower middle class people and getting their votes.

What a smart tactics!

We have heard that she is the poorest minister and has only got 1 Lac as bank balance, not sure whether it is now up by 2.5 crores as it was reported that she sold her art of that amount in a 3 day exhibition held recently. The funniest thing is that there was so much of demand that she did not sleep during those three nights and just kept on painting to feed to the demand. But still we will call her an artist giving the full benefit of doubt :)

Many politicians in India has benami properties and it is surprising that no one is talking about Mamata's four brothers who all are sitting on heaps on money, can we talk about the occupation of her brothers and their life styles?

But there is a danger that more we ask these questions, more the myth that is been carefully crafted about Mamata will be shattered and the stark reality will come out in front of our naked eyes.

She is undoubtedly the most partisan railway minister India ever had and misused the railway ministry fund to give full page advertisements in all leading dailies of West Bengal almost every day before the elections on the plea of laying foundation stones for railway projects. God only knows how many of them will be ever actually carried out.

Her so called pro-poor policies of not increasing fare are forcing Indian Railways to give 3rd grade service. Even the prestigious trains like Rajdhani Express have now the same ambience like her Kalighat area, filled with filth and absence of any comfort. The Railway catering is almost unpalatable and the entire system of Indian Railways was degraded during her regime (and will continue to do so as she is putting a puppet from her party to run the railways).

The Future of Bengal

Mamata is a one woman show (she will call it a "one man show"), TMC is the most autocratic political parry and there is no place of any democracy. You will see that all these economists and quiz masters will soon be side tracked and the party will be eventually run by ex-Congress gangsters and hooligans of Kalighat.

There is already revenge killings that have started in all over West Bengal and it is shocking to see that TMC workers are recovering arms, how that is possible that unarmed disciplined cadres are recovering weapons from armed people of another party? These are nothing but dirty tricks to malign the communist and put non-bailable cases against communist part workers.

Under Mamata the West Bengal can descend into a complete anarchy as she has little experience of administration. She is already a laughing stock and can become a huge hit to the media when she opens her mouth. She wanted the blessings of Sonia whom she once fought and came out of Congress forming Trinamool but now she is running after the same lady almost begging her to come to the oath function but Sonia did not oblige.

Let us not forget that the same person once used a forged doctorate degree from a phony US university and used to write Dr. Mamata Banerjee which tells the integrity of the person. So how many of you expect a resurrection or a renaissance of Bengal under Mamata? You must be dreaming.

She will be lucky if she can complete the full term and West Bengal will deteriorate under TMC rule.

Share This





Related Blogs by this Author

Other Related Blogs

You may also like

Comments (16)


derebail2009 wrote on 20 May, 2011

I believe Mamata will bring some change to West Bengal, she may accept autonomy for darjeeling, secondly she has bought back TATAS and finally her employment drive will make her popular.

FullMarx wrote on 20 May, 2011

Mr. Deb, can you enlighten us from where you got this piece of information that "she has brought back TATAs"!?

FullMarx wrote on 20 May, 2011

Mamata was restless during the entire swearing-in ceremony and she was looking a bit "crazy" if I may use this word. She is a highly erratic personality and no body can guess what she is going to do the next moment.

tuna wrote on 20 May, 2011

I accept ur statement Deberail! I suport u dude!34 years dynasty is nt an example of democracy!i will tell u mr fullmarx 3/4 th of bengli ppl brought het @CM position! n she really lives a simple life!dun talk bout our ex rulling party nw!they just made our state insolvent!besides max ministers are into some economic scandals!FYI wen DIG police met her she said dont go by colors of the criminals!criminals are criminals!!really our exs could nt dare to say that!!n she is above any myth today!!No one is dreaming!If she does nt perform ppl will throw her out!!Its democracy!!and mostly nothing could be worse than our present bengal!!we are no where!!so lets her perform n den we must talk of her cliches!!

tuna wrote on 20 May, 2011

If u talk bout her brothers !1really i dunno wot they do exactly!!I just heard they are into business!!already our ex party ppl are involved into hidco scandal,mahashari scandal,e CM's daughter has a NGO called aranya!n hope with in few months all will come ouT!!SHE IS D ONLY LADY @ our bengal ,she fought!she started fasting!once whe was thrown out of "Mahakaran" by pulling her hair as she took a rape victim their for justice!!dat was her crime!!she was beaten badly by police @1992 @hazra crossing!!Moreover neither you nor me will judge her!!people will judge her!n she is damn successful today!!

FullMarx wrote on 20 May, 2011

Many of the so called attacks on her were stage managed, do you know that? Hazra crossing is the den of Mamata's supporters and if she was attacked over there then it must be inter-gang rivalry dear Ms. Tuna.

tuna wrote on 20 May, 2011

dear den i must say u read more of politics!dat time she dint introduce TMC!she was part @congress!!dats d incident of 1992..n second incident which i have mentioned dat was 1993!!she was sport minister!n jyoti basu was @Cm chair!!u must know all this before writing dude!!!

tuna wrote on 20 May, 2011

that time HAZRA was nt ever her own fort!! the incidents i hav mentioned far away of d birth of TMC!!n not only Mamata our ex govt beat many ex CMs too like prafulla sen,atulla ghosh!!CPIM govt pointed at them for scandals n bribes!!at last Ajay Mukherjee died @medical college hospital with out good personal care!!our Ex CM!!think of it!!so physical violence is nuthing new for CPIM!!n today all electronic medias including all over inda based news paper n tv channels are writing on dis!!n just dont talk anything with out any proof!!simply i hate it mr FullMarx..:)

FullMarx wrote on 20 May, 2011

Ms. Tuna, please be patient, she has only become the CM today, she is definitely a very shrewd politician no doubt about it but the problem is that she tries to portray herself as if she is good with all other things except politics!

FullMarx wrote on 20 May, 2011

She is claiming n one hand that the government is bankrupt, then why she has sworn in such a huge cabinet today? What all these ministers are going to do? How many ministers we need?

tuna wrote on 20 May, 2011

Dear fullmarx!!I think better both of us should wait n watch!!u only said she cant be insulted @ hazra..so i wanted to remind u history!!C"mon she needs ministers!!she needs a full cabinet!she has to take the oath according to constitutional laws!!she just cant talk bout budget cur before her endorsement!!coz dats being arranged by administration n government!!ans each time it happens!!dis year due such crowd u said so!!each year normal people don make such huge rush!!Did your red govt cut d budget@cabinet time on 2006 or on 2001!!?n FYI u should know that ashim das gupta has accepted today really we are bankrupt!!central helped WB to provide salary for this month!!TOp political leaders who handle the scenario only they are accepting the fact!!n today till date 38 ministers took oath!!n 6 more to join!!to run a state ofcourse we need a huge cabinet!!

tuna wrote on 20 May, 2011

even smallest states like goa,mizoram have got huge cabinet!n mostly each state got fixed numbers!she can not increase numbers of ministers just by her whim!!if u r raising voice for some political party I accept your statements!you have full right!!bt u just cant talk bout cabinet size n budget cut!coz today it was arranged by administration dear!she just can invite few more part members guests!dat was only @her hand...people are just dying to see her single glimpse!n u suggest she should nt invite others!C'mon 3/4 th of bengali elected her!!they need to see deit didi closely.Atlast number of ministers are same yet As was at CPIM time!rather one ministry could be merged dat is sundarbon welfare dept with state welfare n development department!!!!!!!!!!!pls follow some news source!!!

cosmicbomber wrote on 21 May, 2011

Was your Comrade Jyoti Basu a holy saint? This is very unjust that you have stared attacking Mamata and speculating that her government would fail, things cannot go worse than it was under the left rule in Bengal, so don't worry too much :)

cosmicbomber wrote on 21 May, 2011

Mamata leads a simple life, may be it is symbolic but still it is a very hard thing to do even if we call it is gimmick. Is it not better than Comrade Jyoti Basu who was projected as a great leader of toiling mass but had to have his scotch every evening?

tuna wrote on 21 May, 2011

cosmic bomber i support u dear!!!very good go ahead!!

Khair wrote on 18 March, 2012

I don't think having a plain and simple appearance and demeanour is the most important thing for a politician but I know it can help in creating an impression on the public. During my very infrequent visits to Kolkata I had seen a few ministers of the Left Front in dhoti carrying their own bags and doing shopping in street side markets like in Benia Pukur for example. Those sorts of things did not help the Left in the long run. When a party becomes big, invariably lot of other negatives start to creep in and pull it apart from inside, and the party must be able to manage that growth and keep steadfast in their direction. Unfortunately, the CPI(M) and Left Front were unable to do so, as a result they became more and more reliant on their vested interest groups rather than on the people who voted for them, so the people gave them their piece of mind at the ballot box.

Now Mamata Banerjee should be given reasonable time, but don't hold your breath lest you be disappointed again.




 

About this Blogger

about blogger A hard worker middle class Indian nurtured in the cradle of leftists movement in India. Yes, I am a CPM supporter... any problem?

Subscribe to FullMarx's blogs

You can stay up to date with FullMarx's blogs via these feeds.

rssFullMarx's blogs Feed (RSS)